FreeSoft Labs All articles
Cost Analysis

The $60 Watchdog: A Month of Free NVR Software, Squirrel False Alarms, and the Cloud Bill We Didn't Pay

FreeSoft Labs
The $60 Watchdog: A Month of Free NVR Software, Squirrel False Alarms, and the Cloud Bill We Didn't Pay

Photo: refurbished Dell OptiPlex small form factor desktop with two security cameras and network cables on a workbench, via e-furbished.in

At $10 a month, a consumer cloud camera plan feels like a rounding error—until you add a second camera, a doorbell, and the odd cloud storage tier. That was the nudge behind this lab trial: replace a subscription camera setup with free, open-source NVR software on a cheap secondhand PC. In October and November 2026, we ran Frigate, ZoneMinder, and Shinobi on a $60 refurbished Dell OptiPlex 7050 with two $35 ONVIF cameras pointed at a front porch and driveway. The goal wasn't to build a surveillance empire. It was to answer a budget question: what does a free NVR actually cost in electricity, storage wear, and 2 a.m. squirrel alerts?

The Setup: A $60 Box and Two Cheap Cameras

The OptiPlex came from a local surplus shop: Core i5-6500, 8GB of RAM, a 256GB SSD, and a case that had seen better days. We added a used 2TB surveillance drive for $35 and two no-name 1080p ONVIF bullet cameras at $35 each. Total hardware outlay: $225. The PC ran headless Ubuntu Server 24.04 LTS. Power draw was measured with a P3 Kill A Watt meter at the wall, with both cameras on separate PoE injectors.

What We Measured (and How)

Every NVR got the same two camera streams, the same porch and driveway view, and the same 30-day window. We logged notifications, tagged each one as true (person or vehicle) or false (squirrel, shadow, rain, passing headlights), and checked drive SMART data every morning. Electricity was averaged over the full month. CPU load came from top and the NVR dashboards. Storage was measured as gigabytes written per day to the recording drive.

Frigate: The Grown-Up in the Room

Frigate was the easiest to live with. Its object detection—run on the CPU, no Coral TPU in this budget—filtered out most of the nonsense. Over 30 days it fired 412 alerts; 38 were false, a 9% false-positive rate. Most of those came from a squirrel that treated our porch step like a personal gym and from rain streaks at dusk. Frigate recorded only clips with detected objects, so the 2TB drive barely noticed. Average storage write: 11GB per day. CPU sat around 45% on the i5, and power draw averaged 31W for the PC plus cameras.

Setup took about two hours, including camera substreams and a motion mask for the sidewalk. The UI is not friendly to someone who has never touched YAML, but the documentation is solid. At 2 a.m., Frigate stayed quiet unless a person or car appeared. That alone made it the household favorite.

ZoneMinder: The Storage Furnace

ZoneMinder is the old guard, and it shows. It works, it is free, and it will record anything that moves—including the neighbor's cat, a plastic bag, and every passing cloud shadow. We logged 1,800 alerts in 30 days; 1,100 were false. That is a 61% false-positive rate. Fourteen of those alerts hit between midnight and 5 a.m., mostly from headlights sweeping the driveway.

Storage was the bigger issue. With continuous recording enabled for two 1080p streams, ZoneMinder wrote about 43GB per day. The 2TB drive was fine for a month, but a three-camera setup would push it. CPU load was lower—around 25%—because the motion detection is simpler, but disk I/O was constant. Electricity averaged 33W. ZoneMinder is a tinkerer's tool, not a set-and-forget porch watch.

Shinobi: The Middle Child

Shinobi landed between the two. Motion zones helped cut some false alerts, but not all. We counted 950 notifications, 410 false—43%. Squirrels and delivery drivers triggered it, though the delivery driver alerts were at least useful. Storage averaged 28GB per day with motion-triggered recording. CPU hovered near 35%, and power draw was 32W.

Shinobi's web interface is friendlier than ZoneMinder's, but we hit two bugs: a stream that dropped after a camera reboot and a notification delay that stretched to 90 seconds. For a free project, it is respectable. For a front porch, the accuracy gap matters.

The Actual Monthly Bill

NVR Alerts (30 days) False alerts Storage per day Avg. power Est. monthly power cost
Frigate 412 9% 11GB 31W $3.79
ZoneMinder 1,800 61% 43GB 33W $4.03
Shinobi 950 43% 28GB 32W $3.91

Electricity at $0.17 per kWh, our local US rate. The free software is free; the hardware and power are not. If you already own a spare PC, the marginal monthly cost is basically the power bill plus drive wear. If you are buying everything for this project, our $225 setup amortized over three years adds about $6.25 per month. That puts the total around $10 per month—roughly the same as a single-camera cloud plan, but without per-camera fees or a privacy trade-off.

What Survived the Month

Frigate survived best. It was not perfect—CPU inference on a six-year-old i5 is not a magic trick—but it kept the alert stream sane and the drive mostly idle. ZoneMinder survived as a project, not as a product; it is great if you want to learn how NVRs work and do not mind tuning motion zones for a week. Shinobi is worth a look if you need a browser-based UI and can tolerate some missed alerts.

One more cost nobody puts on the box: time. We spent about six hours on initial setup across all three, plus another three hours tuning masks, zones, and notifications. At a modest $25 per hour, that is $225 of labor—more than the hardware. If your goal is simply to stop paying a cloud subscription, a free NVR can do it. If your goal is a zero-maintenance porch watch, budget for the tuning time.

The porch-pirate verdict: the squirrels still won the alert-volume contest, but Frigate won the month. The $60 OptiPlex is still humming in the lab, and the cloud subscription is still canceled.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Scanner Was $25; the First 60 Days Cost $955: Three Free Document Vaults, Tested

The Cheap Part Was the Computer: A 45-Day Trial of Three Free CRMs

The Cheap Part Was the Computer: A 45-Day Trial of Three Free CRMs

Fifty Contracts, Three Free E-Sign Servers, and a $60 Dell: The 30-Day Invoice

Fifty Contracts, Three Free E-Sign Servers, and a $60 Dell: The 30-Day Invoice