FreeSoft Labs All articles
Lab Benchmarks

What 60 Nights of SMB Backups Taught Us About a $70 Secondhand NAS

FreeSoft Labs
What 60 Nights of SMB Backups Taught Us About a $70 Secondhand NAS

Photo by Photo by Yoga Sukma 🇮🇩 on Unsplash on Unsplash

The pitch: a backup target for less than a decent dinner

A five-person shop does not need a rack. It needs a place where last night's files can land, and a way to get them back without calling a consultant. That was the whole brief for this test: build a backup target from a secondhand US office PC, install free software, and run it long enough to stop being polite about the results.

The box was an HP EliteDesk 800 G2 small form factor, picked up at a Goodwill for $70. It had an i5-6500, 8GB of RAM, a 256GB SATA SSD, and the usual office grime. We added two drives from the lab pile: a 2TB WD Blue that had been in a desktop since the Obama administration and a 4TB Seagate IronWolf that had seen light use in a previous project. Mismatched, not matched, and definitely not a RAID love story.

We installed the current OpenMediaVault release on the SSD, created two SMB shares, and pointed the shop's nightly backup jobs at them. Then we waited. And measured.

The setup, without the fantasy

This was not a high-availability build. There was no RAID card, no ECC memory, no redundant power supply, and no UPS in the first week. The 2TB drive held workstation images and a folder of scanned invoices. The 4TB drive held the nightly file-level backups from two Windows PCs, one Mac, and a Linux box. OpenMediaVault handled users, shares, SMART monitoring, and email alerts.

The shop's data set was not huge: about 38GB of changed files per night after dedupe-friendly compression on the client side, plus a weekly full copy of a 112GB shared folder. That is small enough to be realistic for a lot of small offices, and big enough to make a $70 PC sweat a little.

Throughput: fine for backups, not a video-editing SAN

Large sequential copies over the built-in 1GbE NIC landed between 108 MB/s and 112 MB/s. That is basically line rate for gigabit Ethernet, and it is more than enough for overnight jobs.

Mixed small-file work was the usual story. A folder of 24,000 invoices, PDFs, and spreadsheets moved at 42 MB/s to 58 MB/s over SMB. The nightly 38GB job finished in 14 to 19 minutes. The weekly 112GB full copy took 26 to 31 minutes, depending on how many small files were in the mix.

A full restore drill was the interesting part. We restored 112GB to a fresh Windows 11 VM over SMB in 26 minutes. Not bad for a machine that cost less than a replacement laptop battery. If you are backing up a few dozen gigabytes a night, this class of hardware is not the bottleneck. Your clients and your Wi-Fi are.

Power draw: the quiet part of the bill

We put the box on a Kill A Watt for the full 60 days. Idle draw was 21W to 23W with the drives spun down. Under backup load it peaked at 34W. Average across the test was about 26W.

At a US residential rate of $0.17 per kWh, 60 days worked out to roughly $6.40. Call it a rounding error next to cloud storage for the same data. The catch is that this number only stays cute if you do not add a UPS, a proper backup drive rotation, and the time you spend babysitting SMART reports.

SMART warnings: the drives had opinions

By week three, the 2TB WD Blue was showing eight reallocated sectors and a handful of pending sectors. OpenMediaVault's SMART page flagged it, and the email alert worked. We did not ignore it. We also did not pretend it was a crisis. The drive was old, the data on it was replaceable, and the whole point of the test was to see what the software would tell us.

The 4TB IronWolf looked clean at first. Then we saw UDMA CRC errors climb after we rerouted a SATA cable to fit the case closed. That is a cable problem more often than a drive problem, and replacing the cable stopped the count. This is the kind of boring detail that separates a lab test from a YouTube build video.

The pulled-drive test

On day 41, with a backup job writing to the 4TB share, we pulled the SATA power connector. This is not a recommended maintenance procedure. It is a test.

The OpenMediaVault web UI stayed up. The 2TB share stayed available. The 4TB share disappeared from the SMB tree. The Windows client threw an error and the backup job failed. The kernel log filled with I/O errors for the missing device. After we powered the box down, reconnected the drive, and booted it back up, the filesystem mounted and the share returned. We ran a read check on the last backup set and found no corruption in the files we sampled.

That is the honest behavior of a non-redundant NAS: one drive goes away, one share goes away. No rebuild, no parity, no heroics. If that sentence makes you nervous, good. It should.

Where the $70 math stops working

The $70 PC plus free software is a genuinely useful backup target. It is not a backup strategy. Once you add a second copy of the important data, a cheap UPS, and a replacement for the aging 2TB drive, you are closer to $250 to $350 in real cost. That is still cheap for a small shop, but it is not the fairy tale the thrift-store receipt suggests.

Our take: use this setup as a local landing zone for nightly SMB backups, keep a second copy somewhere else, and treat SMART alerts as work orders, not decoration. The $70 NAS earned its place in the lab. It just did not earn a cape.

All Articles

Related Articles

One Tiny Pi, Five Screaming Devices: 30 Days of Free DNS Filtering on a $35 Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W

One Tiny Pi, Five Screaming Devices: 30 Days of Free DNS Filtering on a $35 Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W

The 500-Page Office Test: Three Free Wikis on a $60 Secondhand Mini PC

The 500-Page Office Test: Three Free Wikis on a $60 Secondhand Mini PC

Twenty 'Can You See My Screen?' Calls Later: Three Free Remote-Support Stacks on a $99 Mini PC

Twenty 'Can You See My Screen?' Calls Later: Three Free Remote-Support Stacks on a $99 Mini PC